Home/Reviews
Fresh experiences from real runners, collected from Reddit, YouTube and blogs and linked to their sources.
Blog · iRunFar – Craig Randall · 2 days ago
Extremely happy with the fit, comfort and looks: a roomy, cushy forefoot suited his wide, bunion-prone feet and eased his metatarsalgia, and it's a blast at normal paces on smooth trails. But the wavy, sparsely lugged outsole gets clumsy at speed on steep technical terrain. Very pricey.
Blog · Believe in the Run – Taylor Bodin · 2 days ago
No plate, no problem: one of the smoothest shoes he's ever run in, with gobs of soft cushion and a true bounce when pushing. He felt himself gliding over the trail, and his feet felt fantastic after long runs. Priced as a racer, it could equally be a superbly made daily shoe for comfort-first runners.
Blog · Switchback Travel – Maggie Slepian · 2 days ago
The shoe that made running fun this season: the most stable, locked-in feel she's tested, well-spaced lugs that grip on steep terrain, and rebound second to none. The upper, outsole and lugs still look new, unlike shoes she's worn smooth in under 200 miles. Sizing ran nearly a full size off.
Blog · RunToTheFinish – Alyssa Leib · 2 days ago
83%: grip this good, light, bouncy cushioning and a snug, secure fit let a Golden, Colorado trail runner pick up the pace on technical trails. But it's very narrow with no wide option, it only comes in unisex sizing and one bright colourway, and the lacing can't be adjusted, so it's not a go-to for everyone.
Blog · Run Oregon – Matt Rasmussen · 2 days ago
A lightweight, high-performance trail racer that thrives on short, fast, technical efforts: smooth over rolling hills and short, steep climbs, with energy return that stays controlled on descents. All Terrain Contagrip bites well on dry rocky singletrack. Not for muddy slogs or 50-mile days.
Blog · Believe in the Run – Taylor Bodin · 2 days ago
Still an exciting, versatile racer, now centred on technical terrain: extra protective foam and a bit more stability give it reach for efforts up to 4–6 hours, though it's less suited to smooth trails. But a pinch in the throat cost forefoot mobility, and chunks of foam were missing after his first 2-hour run.
Blog · Running Shoes Guru – Olivia Yoder · 2 days ago
A lightweight, well-made, great-looking entry-level road-to-trail shoe for gravel paths, dirt roads and mild trails, with little outsole wear after 50+ miles. It was firm and constrictive, needing many runs to break in, felt too high for her weak ankles on rocks, and the upper held water.
Blog · Doctors of Running · 2 days ago
A solid, lighter rockered trail shoe with good ground feel and some road-to-trail ability, best for moderate miles on mild to moderately technical trails; little outsole wear at 40 miles. A go-to for horse and bluff trails, if a tad flexible up front on climbs. Another tester wants more forefoot room.
Blog · Believe in the Run · 2 days ago
One tester sees it as a sign On is turning a corner: Helion foam and CloudTec pods work surprisingly well from sidewalks to gravel rail-trails. But it's narrow with a shallow toe box that left his big toe aching; size up half. Another tester: light and versatile, but too rigid for 10–15+ miles or technical terrain.
Blog · RunToTheFinish – Constance Mahoney · 2 days ago
A significant update (93%): plenty of stable, slightly springy cushion that kept her legs fresh on long runs, downhill impact absorption so good she forgot her shoes, and chevron lugs that bite better into loose dirt and rock. Good for hot trail runs. The midfoot is snug, and there's no high-energy pop.
Blog · Road Trail Run · 2 days ago
One tester (8.85/10): a comfortable, protective ride with excellent lockdown over varied terrain and a very durable build, though not the lightest; she rolled an ankle in a race, so heel stability needs work. Another tester: not light at 316 g but never sluggish, balanced and controlled, with enough cushion for ultras.
Blog · CleverHiker – Nathan Allen · 2 days ago
One of the more comfortable trail shoes they tested: solid for everyday training, with good traction, excellent on mixed pavement, dirt and gravel, breathable and stable, with no durability issues near 100 miles. The midfoot runs narrow; not ideal for technical, steep or slick trails or racing. 4.1/5.
Blog · Believe in the Run · 2 days ago
Both were On sceptics; past road models left rocks wedged in the outsole. Fans of On's signature ride will find it a great fit: lightweight, responsive and firm, with a connected-to-the-ground feel plus the durability and traction trails need. On won him over on pavement and now on the trails too.
Blog · iRunFar – Natalie Chirgwin · 2 days ago
An excellent choice for mountain running, technical trails or simply going fast, with a lightweight, responsive ride and a breathable yet protective upper; smooth even on concrete. After 150 miles the upper shows minimal wear, though midsole longevity is unproven. The forefoot fits slightly tight.
Blog · Believe in the Run · 2 days ago
Great and comfortable but too close to the Pegasus Trail 5 for $10 more: a plush road-to-trail grinder. Another tester found it uber-comfortable but wobbly on technical descents, with forefoot slide and an unstable heel. A third tester found it narrow, a bit heavy and short on traction, but great on gravel.
Blog · Gearist – Brandon Wood · 2 days ago
A switchblade of a shoe: it cruises easy miles or goes whip-fast without fuss, with an upper that holds the foot on any terrain and no break-in. After 60 miles, much of it on abrasive rock, there's very little wear. It may feel stiff for cushion lovers, it's narrow-ish in the midfoot, and $260 prices many out.
Blog · iRunFar – Alli Miles · 2 days ago
After 250+ miles she trusts it opening up on steep descents, hopping boulders and scrambling peaks: a high-performance trail trainer and racer whose durable build handles sky races to cruisy ultras. Fun for daily runs, but the price reflects super-shoe tech; runners without big goals don't need it.
Blog · iRunFar – Kristin Zosel · 2 days ago
Her favourite shoe in the line and one of her all-time favourite lightweight daily trail shoes: a smooth heel-to-toe roll with firm, efficient energy return that invites pushing the pace. At ~150 miles the upper hasn't stretched and the outsole looks new. It's not burly enough to be an all-mountain shoe for her.
Blog · Believe in the Run · 2 days ago
Possibly one of the best walking shoes money can buy and a solid all-rounder from roads to trails; fans of the last version will love it as much or more. Another tester recommends it for gravel and dry, groomed trails and for anyone wanting higher drop. A third tester: one of Nike's best 'everything' shoes.
Blog · Runnea UK – Imanol Urrestizala · 2 days ago
An ultra trail runner found it perfect up to 10–12 km, secure and responsive, and fine on road-to-trail mixes, but a ~20 km mountain route left his feet tired. A versatile, comfortable, affordable gateway trail shoe, soft yet stable; traction and durability could improve, and it's not for technical terrain.
Blog · Running Shoes Guru – Henry Howard · 2 days ago
Wise improvements over the debut model: even lighter and built for speed, a reputable option for shorter trail days on flat, fast surfaces, and it held up reasonably well after 50 miles. It's niche, not for muddy, snowy or technical terrain or distances over a half marathon, and the narrow forefoot won't suit everyone.
Blog · iRunFar – Alli Miles · 2 days ago
After 100+ miles it still has a place for a specific runner: light, fast and fun, and a cheaper unplated alternative to $250 racers. The glove-like fit suits long, standard-width feet with a narrow heel and may be too snug for wide feet. Not an ideal daily trainer; plated shoes do better at 50K+.
Blog · Doctors of Running – David Salas · 2 days ago
A traditional racing flat for the trails: fun, fast, nimble and aggressive, with good forefoot and midfoot lockdown, good traction and a grounded base. A very good option for sub-ultra trail racing. The heel isn't secure enough on sharp turns and switchbacks, and it struggles in mulchy or soft mud.
Blog · Believe in the Run · 2 days ago
One tester enjoyed it as a rotation shoe for short, speedy trail runs, almost the anti-HOKA: light, interesting and fun on non-technical trails. But $160 is a bit much for such a specific shoe, and the foot shape may exclude many runners. He suggests the cheaper Altra Superior or Nike Terra Kiger.
Blog · iRunFar – Nick DiMarco · 2 days ago
After about 180 miles of mud, wet rock, roots, snow and road it gets about 90% of the job done everywhere. It's fast, durable and confidence-inspiring, with a controlled, reliable ride despite its aggressive look. At 304 g it only felt heavy next to lighter race shoes. Good long-term value for training and racing.
Blog · Believe in the Run – Sam Edgin & Taylor Bodin · 2 days ago
One tester expected a quick, aggressive rattlesnake, but once he dropped that idea he grew really fond of it: capable, protective and stable, with lots of life underfoot and a premium fit. More yak than mountain goat, a solid high-performance max-stack option. A bit bottom-heavy, and $185.
Blog · Road Trail Run – Marcel Krebs & Nils Scharff · 2 days ago
Saucony surprised everyone: a max-cushioned trail shoe with great energy return that many will love, and its outsole sheds mud very well. But it's heavy, and a slimmer upper and less massive outsole would turn a very good shoe into an even better one. They hope a lighter ride sibling follows.
Blog · Doctors of Running – Matt Klein · 2 days ago
An extremely durable, tough trail run/hike shoe for long runs, challenging terrain and climbs, best for those who land farther forward because of the forefoot Speed Roll and little bevel. The upper is tough and secure. It fits short at first, and the major stiffness makes slow-speed transitions unstable.
Blog · Believe in the Run – Taylor Bodin, Alex & Kyle · 2 days ago
One tester finds it underwhelming for the Endorphin name, more Shift than Speed: blocky and heavy, with Speedroll fighting lateral moves (once nearly rolling an ankle) and a narrow-ish toe box. But PWRRUN PB is protective and bouncy, the upper locks in superbly, and traction surprised.
Blog · Alastair Running – Alastair Dixon · 2 days ago
A smart extension of the road v3: the same stable, predictable, grounded and protective ride, plus grip for gravel, light trails and wet roads. Best at steady paces, not energetic. It's ~12 g heavier and less breathable, so it traps heat in humid weather, and the sockliner allows some shifting underfoot.
Blog · Believe in the Run – Taylor Bodin, Renee Krusemark & Matt Kucharski · 2 days ago
One tester: a solid daily trainer that crosses to light trail and handles pace, and a shoulder-season workhorse in Gore-Tex. Another tester, on rural gravel, finds it light, affordable and fine for 20+ mi long runs to speedwork, but its outsole is barely beyond a road shoe's, so she'd want trail rubber for mud, snow and.
Blog · Runner's World – Urs Weber · 2 days ago
A very good shoe that fixes every criticism from their v1 test: more toe room yet very good midfoot hold, a sock-like collar that keeps out stones and more cushion under the ball. A versatile road/trail hybrid with moderate cushioning and good wet grip. Testers advise socks with a cuff to avoid collar rub.
Blog · Trail & Kale – Alastair Dixon · 2 days ago
Hits it out of the park for long-distance trail runners: lighter, with a reshuffled MissionGrip that grips much better on steep downhills, a lower 6 mm drop, more flexibility, a comfier heel and ankle, a softer Helion midsole and better breathability. On calls it max cushion, but it's closer to medium.
Blog · Road Trail Run – Renee Krusemark & Jeff Valliere · 2 days ago
One tester enjoyed it: not hugely different from v1, but much more runnable with a softer midsole, and fun on shorter efforts despite its firmness, with an ounce shaved off.
Blog · Believe in the Run – Taylor Bodin, Reese Ruland & Sam Edgin · 2 days ago
Like driving a sports car: some grip and a whole lot of rip. On smoother terrain, gravel roads or pavement-to-light-trail it will bring a smile to your face, and best in class when fast on smooth ground. Push it too far and that smile flips fast; it lacks the terrain range of rivals like the Summit Vectiv Pro 2.
Blog · Doctors of Running – Matt Klein · 2 days ago
A super-stack, carbon-plated racer for those wanting a firmer, stiffer, aggressive and fast ride, with a secure fit and road-to-trail versatility. The heel and midfoot are unstable for its height, it's a bit too firm and stiff, the toe guard is abrasive and the lace lining poky, so socks are a must.
Blog · Tom's Guide – Nick Harris-Fry · 2 days ago
A dream on hard-packed or gravel paths and road-to-trail runs, where its propulsive bounce and plate shine, and it grips well wet and dry. On testing terrain those features become concerns: it feels unstable and lacks traction on mud or boggy grass, so it's worth the price only to a few.
Blog · Meta Endurance – Theo & Esther · 2 days ago
Stiff and highly responsive, best for shorter, fast trail runs under six hours and speed sessions, not ultras, and your muscles need time to adapt. One tester loved it on climbs, but mud sticks to the outsole until it gets slick.
Blog · Believe in the Run – John Calabrese, Renee Krusemark & Michael Loutzenheiser · 2 days ago
Solid value at $165: it felt great on all sections of a PR run and even road paces in the high 7s, though his foot shifted on hard rocky ground. Another tester's lateral ankles were irritated on descents by the heel counter, and a third tester, a veteran of nearly 100 reviews, finds the upper and laces.
Blog · Treeline Review – Sam Schild · 2 days ago
A balanced trail shoe that disappears underfoot in the best way, neither too cushy nor too supportive, with Vibram Megagrip gripping rock and dirt wet or dry. Durability is average, and they expect 400+ mi. The toe box is wider than v5's, but very wide feet may still find the midfoot too narrow.
Blog · Believe in the Run – Michael Loutzenheiser, Sam Edgin & Melissa Guillen · 2 days ago
Once he ignored the heel and dialled in the fit, one tester really enjoyed it: the foam and Carbitex plate felt quick and zippy, and the outsole was secure on technical descents. The heel still isn't right for the others, sitting low and roomy and letting in rocks until heel-lock lacing fixed it.
Blog · Doctors of Running – Matt Klein · 2 days ago
A fun shoe to log miles in. It excels on longer efforts where consistency matters, and the midsole/plate gets bouncier and snappier at speed with good grip and an anatomic toe box. This first version needs work: a slightly long fit, a loose heel, it's expensive, and it isn't max-stack.
Blog · Live For The Outdoors – Lily Canter · 2 days ago
Promising on paper, but mixed in practice: it's light, grippy, has a wide toe box and suits zero-drop lovers. Yet it lacks rebound for a carbon-plated shoe, the cushioning is limited, the upper feels restrictive, and the heel buckles.
Blog · iRunFar – Molly Schmelzle · 2 days ago
The underfoot feel, performance and tech are a cause for celebration: Ego Max rim, Ego Pro core and a Carbitex plate excel on dirt and inspire fast running. Vibram Megagrip is reliable. It rides best at or near race pace, so she'll keep it for 50K-and-under races. The heel still needs grippier lining to stop slippage.
Blog · Road Trail Run – Mike Postaski, Jeff Valliere & Jana Herzgova · 2 days ago
A clear win for one tester: a go-to for easy, cruisy days and multi-day events, with a foot-shaped toe box, smooth balanced cushioning, no lower-leg stress and fast fun when pushed.
Blog · Believe in the Run – Taylor Bodin · 2 days ago
Altra's first trail shoe with drop is just easy, relaxed for runs where terrain and effort line up. He enjoys it more than the Outroad or Lone Peak, with a roomy, soft knit upper that keeps its shape. His worry is build quality: after only ~20 mi, the out-of-box softness was already fading faster than most.
Blog · RunToTheFinish – Aimee Morey · 2 days ago
About as close to perfect as a trail shoe gets: the traction they've long loved, a consistent slimmer true-to-size fit, and just a smidge more cushion make it an all-day shoe for almost any terrain, restoring confidence after a lacklustre v15. It can run narrow for some, and it isn't the lightest fast option.
Blog · Believe in the Run – Sam Edgin & Allison Mercer · 2 days ago
An update with trade-offs: still the technical grinder that rips up any trail, and with Vibram it's functionally better than ever, with huge grip and a wide toe box. But for one tester the magic of v15's foam, plate and upper blend is gone, so it feels lesser. Sizing was an issue.
Blog · iRunFar – Travis Liles · 2 days ago
He's always had a soft spot for this shoe, and this one strikes a nice balance between the old low, flat ground feel and a bit more cushion and time-on-feet comfort, with a modern Vibram Megagrip outsole. Every run so far has gone well: low, cushioned, grippy, with a nice upper. No complaints.
Blog · OutdoorGearLab – Matthew Richardson · 2 days ago
Hard to beat if you want one trail shoe for everything from technical routes to moderate singletrack. The Vibram outsole fixes the line's longest-standing weakness, and the added cushioning extends its range without losing its technical feel. Less suited to dedicated mud running or ultras that need more stack.
Blog · Road Trail Run – Jeremy Marie · 2 days ago
At its best on runnable terrain: foam, nylon plate and rocker give a fluid, economical, very easy stride with less excessive rebound than a Tecton X 3 and more security. The medium lugs handle road sections. Specific conditions (slick, muddy) are its limit. Lugs show only slight wear at ~100 km.
Blog · Believe in the Run – Taylor Bodin, Reese Ruland & Michael Loutzenheiser · 2 days ago
One tester found it glorious on the trails: every part is premium quality, and the whole works even better. Upper materials, serrated race laces and a higher heel collar give a secure fit without strangling the foot. The new Missiongrip and shallow lugs gripped well in most conditions and transition smoothly between surfaces.
Blog · Better Trail – Alex King · 2 days ago
The upper and midsole are strong: after ~400 mi there's only cosmetic pilling, and the foam still feels good. The outsole is the big problem. Lugs wore down across the whole sole until it's close to bald, and wet, muddy or snowy traction is only average and worsens with wear. Too pricey for a daily driver.
Blog · iRunFar – Craig Randall · 2 days ago
On's most mature, well-rounded trail shoe yet, a sign it's finally getting serious about ultra and mountain running. He pushed descents where he'd normally back off. The lugs aren't aggressive, so it's not a mud shoe, and slick rock, wet roots or thick clay call for caution because the rubber lacks wet stickiness.
Blog · Runner's World UK – Ali Ball · 2 days ago
Comfortable yet agile with impressive energy return: the carbon plate kicks in when you get on your toes. The Megagrip lugs are too small for mud and very technical ground, and the Energy Arc gap traps stones. The fit is very snug, so she sized up; wide feet and ultra runners should look elsewhere.
Blog · Trail Runner – Brian Metzler · 2 days ago
An agile, high-performance trail racer that delivers: soft, resilient FuelCell with a firm-but-not-rigid plate, nimble and stable thanks to the lower forefoot, and Vibram grip on dirt, gravel and wet or dry rock. Mud, scree and alpine technical terrain aren't its thing, and toe protection is modest.
Blog · Road Trail Run – Jeff Beck & Jeff Valliere · 2 days ago
This big, burly shoe now infringes on Bondi territory on the road while being far more trail-competent and planted than soft rivals: firmer, predictable foam, great rock protection and traction. It weighs over 13 oz in a US 11, has no heel pull tab, and a mm or two more width would be welcome.
Blog · Doctors of Running – Matt Klein & David Salas · 2 days ago
Graded A-: One tester keeps reaching for it for easy days on nearly any terrain. It's very stable for a neutral shoe thanks to the H-frame, sole flare, sidewalls and solid traction. The fit is low volume, and the toe cap can rub.
Blog · Believe in the Run – John Calabrese & Michael Loutzenheiser · 2 days ago
A Swiss Army knife for easy to medium days on mixed surfaces, with a perfect fit for one tester, rock-steady support and a plush upper. It's a whopper, too big for racing or technical descents, where the forefoot and midfoot felt a little loose. Party pace only.
Blog · The French Run – Alexandre · 2 days ago
Bought for trail, it became his main training shoe, and he liked it so much he bought an identical second pair to rotate. As a supinator, the side lugs have worn smooth, hurting grip off-camber and in mud. He expects 650–700 km, maybe ~1,000 km for a neutral runner.
Blog · Road Trail Run – Zack, Sam & Dominique · 2 days ago
Familiar trainer comfort with trail support and protection, great for mixing trail, gravel and road. The sturdy outsole is versatile, though one tester wonders how the rubber will wear on road.
Blog · iRunFar – Kristin Zosel · 2 days ago
She absolutely loves it for daily runs on buffed singletrack, gravel and dirt roads, especially on longer or beat-up days when she wants extra cushioning. The Pegasus Trail 5 and Pulsar feel speedier and more agile.
Blog · Runmag – Florent · 2 days ago
His first Brooks won him over: fast on runnable trail and versatile in the end, ideal from 25–30 km up to marathon-length trails. He couldn't test it in wet conditions as the trails had dried, and suspects that could be its Achilles heel.
Blog · Journal du Trail – Vincent Gaudin · 2 days ago
More versatile than v3 without losing its dynamic DNA: a thicker sole and more cushioning widen its range while staying playful, with a well-locked heel and comfort on runnable paths. Grip is only fair on wet ground, the cushioning is limited for ultras, and mesh durability is uncertain.
Blog · Believe in the Run – Taylor Bodin, Reese Ruland & Allison Mercer · 2 days ago
Didn't live up to the hype: the firm midsole held back the tech, leaving one tester disappointed, though he calls it still decent, more protective and stable.
Blog · OutdoorGearLab – Matthew Richardson · 2 days ago
A light, stable, comfortable ride and one of the best Brooks trail shoes they've tested, recommended for beginners and experienced runners on easy-to-moderate terrain. It can feel overly rigid on technical ground, and they prefer the lighter, more nimble v3.
Blog · CleverHiker – Ian Krammer · 2 days ago
Reliable for long-term use: very breathable for hot desert and humid forest runs, with a protective toe cap, excellent laces and a locked-in fit, and minimal wear after 500 mi. It's expensive and a bit narrow, the plate feels stiff on asphalt and hardpack, and traction falls short on soft terrain.
Blog · Better Trail – Jenny Abegg · 2 days ago
Their favourite Brooks trail shoe: light, firm and fast-feeling, with an exceptionally stable ride, locked-in fit and consistent traction from slick rock to dirt. Comfortable enough for 30 miles. The firm, moderate cushioning lacks comfort for long or recovery days, and it's less lively than earlier versions.
Blog · Journal du Trail – Vincent Gaudin · 2 days ago
Revives the classic with liveliness and Vibram grip: softer, taller and more reactive, filtering the ground better and faster on runnable sections. A trusted shoe for 60 km+ on any terrain. The trade-off is less stability on off-camber ground, less precision in technical sections and a snugger forefoot.
Blog · Outdoor Adept – Livia Moreanu · 2 days ago
The rebuild worked for her: dependable grip on wet rock, steady on rocky, sloping ground, and the firmer foam held up on long days. With no rock plate a few sharp points came through, though none hurt. Wet grass soaks through the mesh within 10–15 minutes and damp roots are less sure.
Blog · Better Trail – John Ellings · 2 days ago
Very few shoes do it all like v20: stable, cushioned for big efforts and excellent Vibram traction on and off trail. The thin collar lining frayed at the ankle and heel, the toe box is slightly low, and the wide base keeps it from feeling sporty.
Blog · iRunFar – Alli Miles · 2 days ago
After hundreds of miles in v18 and v19, she switched into it mid-race and ran the last 80 miles of a 100-miler in it, with her foot locked in and the shoe responsive throughout. She's convinced it's the best version yet, evolved from a clunky 'meh' shoe into one of her favourites for everyday runs or ultras.
Blog · Courir Mieux – Margaux de Chanaleilles · 2 days ago
The evolution she was waiting for: real progress in liveliness and rockers, and she finds it a genuinely successful shoe. Three caveats: stability can fall short on truly mountainous terrain, the foam won't please those wanting lots of pop, and grip is only average if you want serious bite.
Blog · Doctors of Running – David Salas · 2 days ago
Very versatile while keeping great cushioning and ride at easy paces, with a well-done rocker for long outings and excellent stability from tall sidewalls and full-contact outsole. Immense value at $160. The upper is snug through the midfoot, and it slips a little on wet rock.
Blog · Believe in the Run – Renee Krusemark, Sam Edgin & Chad Zimmermann · 2 days ago
A comfort shoe through and through: the soft but not mushy midsole and RelieveSphere insole really diffuse uneven impacts. It's almost more comfortable over sharp rocks than on flat ground, which makes it a big-miles shoe worth the gift-card budget.
Blog · GB Ultra Runner – Ash · 2 days ago
A big v2 fan, he wasn't let down: 15 backyard-ultra laps (~100 km) with no blisters or hot spots, and it handled everything with ease. A great all-rounder. The one negative is grip in true UK slop and boggy mud. He has yet to try it on jagged technical terrain.
Blog · Road Trail Run – Jen Schmidt, John Tribbia & Jeff Valliere · 2 days ago
Long miles and medium-to-wide feet? Could be your favourite: max cushion with an energetic ride, surprisingly light, and comfortable for high-mileage training, ultras and hiking. The thick upper holds heat and moisture, traction isn't perfect on wet rock, and low-volume feet can't cinch the midfoot.
Blog · Trailrunning.it – Gianluca Gaggioli · 2 days ago
A shoe any trail runner can take over medium and long distances at any pace and finish with rested feet. It's very protective without bulk, comfortable from 3:50/km pushes to brisk hikes with a 30 L pack, and never feels mushy, though it gives no help at toe-off.
Blog · The Running Club – Davide Bonato · 2 days ago
Very pleasant and comfortable, and he liked it, but the range is limited to easy terrain, door-to-trail and mixed runs. After 150 km the softer Vibram compound showed fairly heavy outsole wear, and he expects no more than ~500 km. Hard to rate low durability highly at this price.
Blog · Believe in the Run – Allison Mercer, Sam Edgin & Melissa Guillen · 2 days ago
Comfortable and good on less technical trails, it shines in hybrid road-and-trail or fire-road running. One tester found the firmness less accommodating as runs went long, and another tester got heel pain on longer runs, perhaps from the drop.
Blog · Doctors of Running – David Salas · 2 days ago
A max-cushion trail shoe with a wide, centred platform, decent traction and good versatility as a daily shoe. The upper gives under medial and lateral forces, so it translates on angled or technical descents, and the forefoot is tapered.
Blog · OutdoorGearLab – Ally Arcuri · 2 days ago
Not an all-round high scorer, but worth considering for its easy comfort, durability and mid-range price. The Vibram tread gives agility and confidence on loose and technical ground, though the lugs aren't as bitey as some. The heel cup hugs the rearfoot well.
Blog · iRunFar – Annie Behrend · 2 days ago
Reliable, plush and comforting, like the Midwest cinnamon rolls that fuelled her first runs in them. It transitions seamlessly from pavement to dirt road and trail on her mixed loops, with enough grip to climb and descend confidently.
Blog · Journal du Trail – Vincent Gaudin · 2 days ago
The A-TPU foam and plate give a clear push as the pace rises. The wide heel feels secure on dry, runnable trails despite the stack, and dry grip convinced him. It's weak in mud, with limited heel hold and little lateral protection.
Blog · Believe in the Run – Taylor Bodin · 2 days ago
He expected a blast-off sensation and was surprised by its efficiency-over-everything feel, but the more he ran the more he loved it: energetic and snappy, like a Metafuji/Tecton X 3 blend. A structured, padded heel anchors the foot far better than the flimsy Tecton X 3 upper.
Blog · iRunFar – Craig Randall · 2 days ago
Less magical than the road v3 but more versatile: lighter, faster and more efficient than most trail shoes, with enough stability and traction where a road shoe would struggle. The A-TPU foam stayed bouncy and responsive for about 100 mi.
Blog · CleverHiker – Nathan Allen · 2 days ago
A comfort-forward, soft but springy racer for hard-packed trail and gravel roads: 10 comfortable, responsive miles out of the box and no durability issues near 100 mi. It's the priciest shoe on their list, niche, and not great on uneven or slick terrain.
Blog · Road Trail Run – Maren & Marcel · 2 days ago
Outstanding propulsion and a reactive FF Leap midsole, and almost road-shoe smooth on paved sections. One tester's first carbon trail shoe. It only comes alive at higher speed and feels too race-oriented for easy runs. Grip is limited in mud, the pointed toe box suits narrow feet, and it's expensive.
Blog · Believe in the Run – Reese Ruland, Renee Krusemark & Taylor Bodin · 2 days ago
An airy, snappy, speedy ride that feels more road-to-light-trail or gravel shoe than do-it-all mountain racer. One tester, who broke her ankle in v1, kept it off technical trail. It was perfect for gravel intervals, and the drawstring laces mostly stay put.
Blog · Live For The Outdoors – James Forrest · 2 days ago
Spectacularly fast but highly specialised: one of the most energetic trail rides he has experienced and a rocket on gravel, runnable climbs and hard-packed paths. The super-high stack gives little lateral stability, so ankle rolls are a real risk on uneven terrain.
Blog · The Running Channel – Mark Dredge · 2 days ago
One of the most impressive trail racers available, comparable to a road super shoe in responsiveness. It only comes alive when you push the pace, best on non-technical, runnable trail. Avoid it if you have weak ankles or Achilles issues or only run easy.
Blog · Run for Fun – funfun · 2 days ago
The 'Suzuki Jimny of trail shoes': minimal and agile, with direct ground feel, Nike Free-level cushioning, and good grip. It's light enough to race short trails, as he did at Hasetsune 30K. The heel cup is shallow, the laces slippery, and it's slightly snugger than other Altras.
Blog · Running Shoes Guru – Denny Krahe · 2 days ago
A long-time Superior fan who only used earlier versions on very non-technical trail, he was pleasantly surprised. The added cushioning fixes the old problems on technical sections. It's light, comfortable and durable. The toe box is narrower than past Superiors.
Blog · Believe in the Run – Michael Loutzenheiser · 2 days ago
The midsole errs on the side of harsh. Without a rock plate there isn't enough stack except on soft dirt or pine needles. It suits a narrow group: zero-drop fans who want a lower-leg strengthening trainer or a sub-ultra racer. He doesn't see it working for most trail runners.
Blog · Journal du Trail – Vincent Gaudin · 2 days ago
Still a must-have for non-technical races up to about 80 km. It climbs and descends well, and the seamless ripstop mesh should last longer. Cushioning is a bit thin, hold on off-camber ground is limited, and weight is up (327 g claimed). The fit runs slightly larger than v6/v7.
Blog · The Trek – Eloise Robbins · 2 days ago
A solid version of everyone's favourite trail runner: if you liked the 7s you'll like these. The wide toe box is the real draw, and they are easier to put on. Durability still lags boots and some trail shoes, though it has improved. She'll use them on her thru-hike and may stockpile pairs.
Blog · Treeline Review – Sam Schild · 2 days ago
The roomy toe box (also in wide) and ground feel remain the draw, and grip handles most conditions. The v8 durability updates seem to be an improvement on earlier uppers that holed out. The gaiter ring is gone, and they find the Topo Timp offers more overall.
Blog · iRunFar – Molly Schmelzle · 2 days ago
Still a favourite zero-drop shoe for its versatility, reliability and comfort: a feel-good sigh of relief on slipping them on. The gusset and functional pull tabs give a snugger midfoot. The outsole isn't overly aggressive or tacky, which also makes it fine for town and field days.
Blog · Runmag – Corentin · 2 days ago
A reliable partner for long and very long distances: cushioned on every type of terrain, comfortable and stable, with a capable outsole. The fit and toe-box width won't suit everyone, so try before you buy.
Blog · WearTesters – Drew Whitcomb & Sam Lohse · 2 days ago
A comfortable, stable cushioned ride with a sticky Vibram outsole. The thick, durable mesh feels supportive but runs hot in summer, and they struggled to get a really solid heel lockdown.
Blog · Road Trail Run – Jen & Jeff V · 2 days ago
The best all-around trail shoe she has tried this year at $170, like favourite jeans. Another tester V found it soft but well stabilised. Laces come untied, it drains poorly, it's heavier than v3, and the foot slides forward on very steep downhills.
Blog · Live For The Outdoors – Milo Wilson · 2 days ago
More than it looks: a bombproof upper, reliable cushioning and an excellent full Vibram Megagrip outsole that gives control without going numb. One of the best ultra shoes he has tested recently. It isn't fast or light, and the lugs aren't ideal in mud.
Blog · Believe in the Run – Taylor Bodin · 2 days ago
Comfort, security and durability are the standouts, and Saucony fixed v3's durability problems. The fit is slightly roomy and the lacing chain is clever. At 338 g it's heavier, and the medium-soft foam dulls liveliness for those wanting a bouncy max-stack shoe. Built to go the distance.
Blog · Treeline Review – Sam Schild · 2 days ago
One of the cheapest shoes they tested at $140, yet it performs like pricier ones. Testers love the stable upper and generously cushioned, bouncy midsole, and say it does almost everything well, from rocky technical trail to muddy rolling paths and long days out.
Blog · Runner's World – Pat Heine (testers Connor Orr, Thomas Hengge) · 2 days ago
Still relatively firm with a thin EVA midsole, but light, secure and durable, with sure grip on dry terrain that let testers bomb loose descents. It slips a bit on wet and snowy surfaces and the forefoot cushioning feels thin. The single-toggle Quicklace is hard to tension.
Blog · GearJunkie – Matthew Medendorp · 2 days ago
He expected to dislike it but it became his highest-mileage shoe of 2023: comfortable, durable and grippy on most terrain, and fine on pavement. He wanted more grip on shale scrambles. Fine dust gets through the mesh, and wide feet may find the Quicklace tight.
Blog · Blister – Scott Vinsel · 2 days ago
Not flashy, but one of Salomon's most reliable trail shoes. It felt stiff and unforgiving for the first ~50 mi before breaking in. He rates it a stellar entry-level and road-to-trail shoe and a no-frills, high-mileage trainer for ultrarunners. Wide or high-volume feet may feel restricted at the collar.
Blog · Journal du Trail – Vincent Gaudin · 2 days ago
Versatile, comfortable and fairly priced, suiting non-technical courses up to about 100 km. Grip on dry and even wet rock surprised him given Salomon's reputation. The weak point is greasy mud, where the lugs don't bite.
Blog · Believe in the Run – Sam Edgin · 2 days ago
Durable, comfortable and protective at a killer price, but it feels slow and bloated. The plate is too flexible, leaving a dead toe-off, and the ride is very firm, though his feet felt fine after ten miles. Best sold as a durable everyday trail shoe rather than a speed shoe.
Blog · OutdoorGearLab – Ally Arcuri · 2 days ago
A 'minimalistic maximalist': comfortable, stable and grippy at a lower price than many favourites. The soft external toe cap makes downhills kind to the toenails, though it's less protective than firmer caps. It finished mid-pack in a competitive test.
Blog · OutdoorGearLab – Aaron Rice · 2 days ago
A near-perfect all-rounder: not the best at any one thing but good enough for almost any trail. He was surprised by how stiff it feels underfoot, yet it stays protective and stable without feeling like pillows. An obvious next step after entry-level shoes.
Blog · The Running Club – Davide Bonato · 2 days ago
Scores 7. Very comfortable (8) even over several hours and on hard ground, and more protective without the Air Zoom unit. It's good value at €105 or less and durable. The big, annoying issue is wet grip: pair it with another shoe for wet days.
Blog · Trail and Kale – Alastair Dixon · 2 days ago
Lighter and with more aggressive grip than v8, making it better on technical trails. It has a thoughtful gusseted tongue, extra lace padding, a toe bumper and improved durability. A true trail all-rounder and worth the upgrade.
Blog · Believe in the Run – John Calabrese, Melissa Guillen · 2 days ago
One tester wouldn't hesitate to toe a 50K start line in it again. It is versatile, with lugs that handle hard trail plus gravel and road, and more stable without the Zoom Air pod. The heel collects debris and the tongue can dig in.
Blog · Gearist – Brandon Wood, Arron · 2 days ago
One tester found thin protection and only short-run cushioning. One of another tester's most go-to trail shoes: nimble and quick, with a durable upper. The redesigned lugs bite well and showed little wear after 50 abrasive miles. There's only a thin rock plate and it lacks some pop of earlier versions.
Blog · Bieganie.pl – Dariusz Korzeniowski · 2 days ago
A new dimension of cushioning for mountain run-walkers who prioritise comfort, beginners and heavier or wide-footed runners. The sole worked fully in testing and drains well on hard terrain. Ventilation was lacking in summer heat.
Blog · Believe in the Run – Robbe Reddinger, Thomas Neuberger · 2 days ago
'Fat tire fun': a set-it-and-forget-it shoe for big, comfortable miles at no specific pace, and it transitions surprisingly well to road. The big Vibram lugs bite in mud but add weight. He'd avoid slippery surfaces, and the lacing throat puckers when cinched.
Blog · Road Trail Run – Jeff B, Jeff V · 2 days ago
A very runnable behemoth: top-of-class cushioning (44 mm measured), solid durable traction and plenty of room for long-run swelling. Ideal for road-to-trail or 25+ mile runs. Low-volume feet may struggle with lockdown, and the wide, tall midsole is heavy (305 g).
Blog · Women's Running – Laura McGoldrick · 2 days ago
Cushioning and bounce kept her legs fresh on a long run, and the 5 mm Vibram lugs grip across terrain, including some road. She couldn't get enough ground feel on challenging terrain, and the stack felt unstable on steep downhills. Yes for long, comfortable runs.
Blog · Doctors of Running – Matt Klein (DPT) · 2 days ago
Rated A/A- overall, personal A-. An extremely comfortable, stable-neutral max trail shoe for long easy efforts and casual wear. It is too big and heavy for anything fast, and he wishes it were lighter. The thick Vibram outsole should last far longer than most max trail shoes.
Blog · Adventure Alan – Jaeger Shaw · 2 days ago
The comfiest, cushiest and grippiest version yet: zero blisters and ache-free feet over 300 miles. The midsole was shot and the tread worn by the end, which is average durability. It rubbed his arches early, there was minor outsole glue failure around mile 150, and the 8 mm drop is a con for him.
Blog · Tom's Guide – Nick Harris-Fry · 2 days ago
His favourite road-to-trail shoe and a safe option for any runner who splits time between surfaces. That versatility cuts both ways: for mountains or mud you'll want a specialist trail shoe.
Blog · iRunFar – Alli Miles · 2 days ago
An excellent everyday shoe for a wide variety of surfaces: highly cushioned, plush and stable, with a roomy toe box. It is versatile on pavement, gravel and non-technical trail and great for travel, but not designed for extreme terrain.
Blog · Believe in the Run – Taylor Bodin, Robbe Reddinger, Alex Elizabeth · 2 days ago
The outsole is sticky on wet, muddy, rocky, technical terrain, and the plate protects from roots and rocks. It is firm: One tester didn't get the promised bounce and wanted a little more stack. Another tester found it narrow in the midfoot.
Blog · Running Lab – Julien Guyod · 2 days ago
A hybrid that challenges the best: excellent dynamism for short and medium races, very good grip on compact, loose, rocky and snowy ground, and little mud build-up. Some testers found the recycled rubber grips slightly less well than v2.
Blog · Journal du Trail – Vincent Gaudin · 2 days ago
Rated 4.25/5. Excellent for performance and precision over medium distances, with good hold, immediate comfort and dynamism. It loses effectiveness on demanding ground: grip is just adequate in the wet, cushioning is limited for ultras, and mesh durability is uncertain.
Blog · WearTesters – Sam Lohse · 2 days ago
A snug, light, high-performance uptempo trail shoe. The main con is the outsole: good, but not grippy enough for rugged, snowy Utah terrain. The laces are short.
Blog · iRunFar – Reese Ruland · 2 days ago
A standout all-purpose trail shoe that balances traction, cushioning and modest responsiveness, with a snug fit. A perfect choice for a lightweight, fast trail shoe.
Blog · Doctors of Running – Matt Klein (DPT) · 2 days ago
Overall grade B. A nimble, snappy, durable uptempo trail racer. One tester's personal grade is B-: similar to last year, the foam is too firm, the plate isn't as snappy as hoped, and it is pricey for what you get.
Blog · Action Magazine – Massimo Barbieri · 2 days ago
Immediately stable and at ease despite the high stack, with smooth rolling and great comfort and protection. On runnable descents you could go blindfolded. On technical descents it is bulky and heavy, and push too hard and the soft foam absorbs your effort. Size up.
Blog · Running Lab – Aurore Rousseau · 2 days ago
A comfortable, dynamic, robust trail monster truck you can trust to take you far almost anywhere. Traction was impeccable on wet climbs. It is a little less flexible and slightly firmer than v2, and heavy on paper (305 g).
Blog · Meta Endurance – Silke, Theo · 2 days ago
'Super comfort cruiser', not for technical trails. One tester made it her go-to trail shoe for its door-to-trail rolling comfort. The laces kept coming untied, and tightening them on a 5-hour run cut circulation and left another tester's feet numb.
Blog · Journal du Trail – Vincent Gaudin · 2 days ago
Rated 4.25/5. Formidably efficient, with an explosive ride, smooth Lightstrike Pro cushioning and precise trajectories. A reference for chasing times. The heel hold could be better, stability is limited, and it is demanding and pricey, so it suits experienced trail runners.
Blog · Believe in the Run – Taylor Bodin, Allison Mercer · 2 days ago
Speed-first through and through: on runnable, predictable trail it is one of the most exciting rides available. Despite the added weight it doesn't feel bottom-heavy. Stability and control on technical trails are the tradeoffs.
Blog · Road Trail Run – Zack, Jeff, Jen, Adam, Dom · 2 days ago
Fast, with great energy return on runnable terrain. It is stiff, high and narrow-heeled, so it tips easily and demands focus on technical ground. The breakpoint is about 10 min/mile: much slower than that, look elsewhere.
Blog · Le Comparatif du Trail – Julian · 2 days ago
Very good cushioning, comfort and grip on soft and loose ground over 160 km. Grip is weak on wet, compact rock, and breathability is limited.
Blog · Runner's World UK – Ali Ball, Rick Pearson · 2 days ago
Gives the confidence to tackle uneven terrain while staying comfortable over several miles. It is like a lovechild of the Speedcross and Ultra Glide 2. Nothing flashy, and at 290 g it isn't for short races.
Blog · Road Trail Run – Sam, Jeff V · 2 days ago
Comfortable, cushioned and grippy on soft ground. The front of the upper lacks hold on technical terrain, and traction on hard and wet surfaces is only average.
Blog · Believe in the Run – Michael Loutzenheiser, Matt Kucharski · 2 days ago
'A winning debut.' A really fun, fast shoe for nimble runners who want more grip and protection than the Sense Ride. The Energy Foam rides comfortably without instability, and the 5 mm lugs are super aggressive.
Blog · Running Shoes Guru – Olivia Yoder · 2 days ago
Confidence on pretty much any terrain: it is sturdy, grips anything, and is light enough to push the pace. The fit is stable and locked-in, and the shoe is durable enough to wear for hours. It runs a little warm.
Blog · The Trek – Anne K. Baker · 2 days ago
An exceptionally durable, highly cushioned ride that is particularly well suited to mud. Size carefully: she suggests ordering your size and a half size down. There is no rock plate, so it leans towards cushion over protection.
Blog · Trail Sage · 2 days ago
'I wanted to like these, but they have not worked out for me.' Subtle changes from the original version hurt it on rock scrambles and rock gardens, and the author can't trust it there. It may suit runners who want less cushioning or who don't run on rocky ground.
Blog · OutdoorGearLab – Ally Arcuri · 2 days ago
Light, comfortable and grippy enough to recommend for mixed terrain and higher trail mileage. It crosses easily to pavement and has a plush-but-not-mushy feel.
Blog · Road Trail Run – Dom, Shannon, Jeff V · 2 days ago
A light, nimble, versatile trail shoe with good durability so far. It is harsh on pavement and its traction on wet rock is poor.
Blog · Cardiff Trails – Jack Davies · 2 days ago
Light and quick, and he wishes he'd bought it sooner. Forefoot grip is poor in wet Welsh conditions, so he saves it for dry days. He would buy it again.
Blog · Runnea UK – Raúl Lozano · 2 days ago
Scores 8.7. Built for consistency and protection over long distances, with plenty of cushioning and strong grip. Outsole durability is the main con after 125 km.
Blog · iRunFar – Annie Behrend · 2 days ago
'Big Blue' stayed impressively comfortable and protective. From mile 65 of a 100-miler it carried her over rocky Wagner Butte and a technical descent at night. The wide platform never felt tippy, and the Megagrip lugs are burly.
Blog · Hunting for Bliss – Paweł · 2 days ago
He calls it 'R.I.P. The series'. On technical Norwegian trail, the tall soft stack felt too unstable at speed, so he returned the shoes. Grip, cushioning and durability were good.
Blog · WearTesters – Sam Lohse, Drew Whitcomb · 2 days ago
It carried one tester through 61 miles of Leadville with protection and cushioning to spare, and it is wide-foot friendly. The tongue is a bit short.
Blog · Treeline Review – Becca Downs + male co-tester · 2 days ago
A comfortable, protective and grippy max-cushion trail shoe for long mountain days. They expect the midsole to give out first, at around 300 mi, and the shoe is pricey.
Blog · Runnea – Alazne Anton, Unatx · 2 days ago
Comfortable and protective over long distances, with a stable platform and good cushioning. It struggles in mud, on wet rock and on very technical ground, where grip and agility are limited.
Blog · WearTesters – Drew Whitcomb · 2 days ago
A plush, stable, durable max-cushion trail cruiser for long days. Its cons are that it is not nimble and is stiffer than some rivals.
Blog · iRunFar – Annie Behrend · 2 days ago
Remarkable stability and protective cushioning for long runs. The roomy neutral fit wasn't ideal for her narrow, pronating feet, but it is a strong pick for most ultra runners.
Blog · Believe in the Run – Sam Edgin, John Calabrese, Allison Mercer · 2 days ago
A comfortable, cushioned, stable long-distance trail shoe that testers call practically a steal. There is excess fabric in the toe box, and lockdown got harder once the upper stretched.
Blog · Mangeurdecailloux – Julien · 2 days ago
A very stable, cushioned all-rounder that feels like a trail SUV and is excellent on soft forest trails. It slips on wet, hard ground (rock and tarmac) and its weight hurts on faster efforts. The foot feels very guided. He suggests it for the Ecotrail 80 or SaintéLyon.
Blog · Référence Trail – Quentin André · 2 days ago
Rated 4.25/5. He recommends it without hesitation for 50 km+ ultras and 30–40-hour races on runnable paths. Cushioning, width and stability are excellent. Performance on technical ground and grip on greasy soil are limited, and the heel hold could be better.
Blog · Journal du Trail – Vincent Gaudin · 2 days ago
Rated 4.25/5. An excellent ultra shoe: big cushioning and comfort for 30–40-hour races, with good traction on mixed ground. It isn't dynamic, and the heel hold could be better. At 308 g it is heavy, so take care on technical and greasy terrain.
Blog · Believe in the Run – Taylor Bodin, Robbe Reddinger, John Calabrese · 2 days ago
A durable, cushioned workhorse that is more nimble than v6. One tester ran 33 mi out of the box with no blisters. Testers expect it to outlast version 6 but wanted more protection on sharp rocks.
Blog · iRunFar – Reese Ruland · 2 days ago
Stable, with great traction and a comfortable fit for long days. The ride felt flat and lacked oomph, so it didn't match her preferences. Still a top pick for runners who want comfort and stability over speed.
Blog · Ian Corless · 2 days ago
His 'shoe of 2021': light, comfortable and fast, with superb Continental grip on rock. It is less convincing in mud. The pair finally failed after 834 km and a Jotunheimen fastpack, which is a long life for a shoe this light.
Blog · Gearselected – charlesr · 2 days ago
A long-term favourite for ultras on runnable trail: light, cushioned and fast, and it got him through 50K and 50-mile races. An update at 550 mi showed the lugs worn down.
Blog · Blister – Gordon Gianniny · 2 days ago
A light, fast, well-cushioned ultra shoe that stayed comfortable through a 50-mile mountain race. The upper's durability is the weak point: an eyelet ripped at around 150 mi.
Blog · Doctors of Running – Matt Klein (DPT) · 2 days ago
B+ overall. With the Edge it forms a stiff/flexible pair that races equally well for different runners. Fine for shorter miles, but he'd like better upper integration and hoped for the Edge's slightly wider forefoot.
Blog · Journal du Trail – Vincent Gaudin · 2 days ago
4/5. A pleasant surprise despite the odd TPU heel piece: effective fit, a good hold despite the PEBA foam, lots of cushioning and a sense of rebound. For distances up to ~80 km. Strengths: comfort, cushioning, grip. Weaknesses: stability, high price.
Blog · Trail and Kale – Alastair Dixon · 2 days ago
Surprisingly comfortable: the gaiter-like collar keeps debris out, it's breathable, and it has a responsive edge. On steep descents the firm toe cap meant his big toe hit the bumper unless the fit was very tight. Less reliable on wet, slick rock.
Blog · iRunFar – Molly Schmelzle · 2 days ago
A softer, more compliant ride: rather than sinking in, the PWRRUN PB and SPEEDROLL geometry help save energy and roll you forward. Tested on rugged, rocky terrain across three states.
Blog · Conor's Bandon Blog – Conor O'Neill · 2 days ago
A possible do-anything trail shoe: very comfortable with a fantastic midsole, closer to his beloved Endorphin Speed than the 'Peregrine horror show', and the outsole is much grippier on stones. His big toe rubbed the bumper, and he suspects the lugs will wear fast on road.
Blog · Running Shoes Guru – Henry Howard · 2 days ago
Close to slippers: better midsole cushioning and a lighter breathable upper make it great for easy to moderate trail days and recovery runs. It doesn't match up on technical terrain or for speed, isn't very grippy, and the toe bumper could be sturdier. He expects 400-500 miles.
