Reddit · r/RunningShoeGeeks · Dec 14, 2025 · summarized
PositiveThey find the Elite v4 really comfy and very bouncy for long runs and tempos, so they plan to skip upgrading to the v5.
Quick note: Some links are affiliate links. We earn a tiny commission if you buy (at no cost to you). Keeps the lights on!

Racing
Bouncy, stable and roomy in the toe box; the main downsides are weight and some heel slip.
A score out of 100 for how well reviewed a product is next to others of its kind. It rises with positive reviews and with how many there are; negative and mixed reviews take points off. The best in each category scores in the 90s.
So a handful of glowing reviews can’t beat a product lots of people like. No sponsored placements.
Showing 12 reviews mentioning responsive Show all
Reddit · r/RunningShoeGeeks · Dec 14, 2025 · summarized
PositiveThey find the Elite v4 really comfy and very bouncy for long runs and tempos, so they plan to skip upgrading to the v5.
Blog · Believe in the Run – Meaghan Murray, Thomas Neuberger, Caryn Just · summarized
PositiveLighter and bouncier than v3, great at any pace, and in one tester's top three for race day. The best New Balance marathon racer ever, with a broad, accommodating base and an adaptable upper, though it could lose a couple of ounces.
Blog · The Running Channel – Mark Dredge, Sarah, Meg · summarized
PositiveReliable and comfortable over 22-26 miles, with an extra push forward, and two testers ran marathon PBs in it. Not for runners who want to feel really fast on race day. Try the width and size first.
Blog · Tom’s Guide – Michael Sawh · summarized
PositiveIt served him well on the streets of London: a durable carbon marathon shoe that isn't just for elites, and one he'd recommend. Cheaper rivals offer similar versatility.
Reddit · r/RunningShoeGeeks · Oct 31, 2024 · summarized
PositiveAn SC Elite v4 owner loves everything but the laces and calls it the springiest shoe they've owned.
YouTube · TheGingerRunner · Mar 1, 2024 · summarized
PositiveUnder 100 miles outdoors and on the treadmill, not raced yet. They love the soft, springy midsole and snappy carbon plate, which stays comfortable instead of harsh. Drawbacks are the high price, a forefoot less roomy than they hoped, a tongue without gussets, and worry that the light mesh upper may not last hundreds of miles, though it holds up so far. They call it a fun shoe for picking up the pace and can imagine racing a half or full marathon in it.
Reddit · r/RunningShoeGeeks · Feb 17, 2024 · summarized
PositiveIn their first plated shoe, a Rebel fan finds the SC Elite v4 soft but not too soft, very responsive and fun across several runs.
Reddit · r/RunningShoeGeeks · Feb 11, 2024 · summarized
MixedOn a tempo run the SC Elite v4 felt bouncy and natural at pace, but its heels rubbed and gave this runner blisters.
Reddit · r/RunningShoeGeeks · Feb 8, 2024 · summarized
PositiveA ~200 lb runner in the 11 wide finds the SC Elite v4 bouncy and aggressive yet protective enough, a bit soft for fast track reps but ideal for road.
Reddit · r/RunningShoeGeeks · Feb 1, 2024 · summarized
PositiveOn a first 6-mile run the SC Elite v4's PEBA FuelCell gave immense energy return and a stable, friendly ride, though it's a little heavy for a super shoe.
Reddit · r/RunningShoeGeeks · Jan 30, 2024 · summarized
PositiveAfter a first 10K, a recreational runner with slightly wide feet calls the SC Elite v4 a major upgrade from the RC Elite v2: taller, more responsive and somehow more comfortable.
YouTube · Believe in the Run · Jan 8, 2024 · summarized
PositiveTwo testers wore these for the New York City Marathon (not raced), with over 60 miles on one pair at review time. They describe a bouncy, fast-feeling, comfortable ride, a wide, secure upper, no traction problems, and feet that felt great over several hours. Negatives are the weight, heavy for a race shoe (about 7 oz in a women's 7.5, over 9 oz in a larger pair), and a felt-like tongue. They see it suiting many runners who want a plated racer that is comfortable.
Most runners find the New Balance FuelCell SuperComp Elite v4 bouncy, comfortable and stable, with a roomy toe box that suits wider feet, and good for long road runs and marathons. The main downsides are weight and some heel slip or rubbing. A few find the low drop and short tongue awkward.
Of the 31 reviews with a clear verdict, 77% are positive, 16% mixed and 6% negative. The praise mentioned most is great for long runs. The most common complaint is heavy.
The complaints reviewers mention most: heavy (1 review). For example: An SC Trainer v2 fan was disappointed by the SC Elite v4: it felt heavy and lacked pep, and a 16-mile run left them completely spent.
We collected and summarized 31 experiences shared on Reddit, blogs and YouTube, with links to the original sources. Reviews submitted here are checked for spam before they appear. Every review, submitted here or collected, is read as positive, mixed or negative.
Plated race-day super shoes and racing flats, ranked by real runners.